Earn Rewards >> Sign up & get 2% store credit back on your purchases
Free Shipping On Purchases Over $75 (US Only)
Over 30,000 LPs IN STOCK
Over 50,000 LPs IN STOCK

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Check out these collections

New Vinyl
Coming Soon
Back In Stock Vinyl
Darkside Records

Stay In The Know

Sign up for our email communications to learn about new releases, preorders, used drops and more!

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

50% Off Select Plush

31 Results

Clear all

31 Results

$
to
$

The highest price is $37.99

Clear all
"Block You Up" Plush

"Block You Up" Plush

$16.99

$16.99

Cute But Toxic Mushroom Plush

Cute But Toxic Mushroom Plush

$16.99

$16.99

Deddy Bear Body Bag 12" Plush
50% off

Deddy Bear Body Bag 12" Plush

$24.99 from $12.50

$24.99 from $12.50

Don't Get It Twisted Pretzel Plush

Don't Get It Twisted Pretzel Plush

$16.99

$16.99

Dungeons & Dragons: Beholder Plush - Darkside Records
50% off

Dungeons & Dragons: Beholder Plush

$15.99 $7.99

$15.99 $7.99

Dungeons & Dragons: Demogorgon Plush - Darkside Records
50% off

Dungeons & Dragons: Demogorgon Plush

$15.99 $7.99

$15.99 $7.99

Dungeons & Dragons: Red Dragon Plush - Darkside Records
50% off

Dungeons & Dragons: Red Dragon Plush

$15.99 $7.99

$15.99 $7.99

Fries Before Guys Plush

Fries Before Guys Plush

$16.99

$16.99

Home Alone - 7.5" Phunny Plush - Kevin - Darkside Records
50% off

Home Alone - 7.5" Phunny Plush - Kevin

$14.99 $7.50

$14.99 $7.50

Livin' The Nightmare Plush

Livin' The Nightmare Plush

$16.99

$16.99

Mini Squishable Baby Cthulhu II

Mini Squishable Baby Cthulhu II

$34.99

$34.99

Mini Squishable Baby Mothman

Mini Squishable Baby Mothman

$34.99

$34.99

Mini Squishable Cerberus

Mini Squishable Cerberus

$34.99

$34.99

Mini Squishable Dark Forest Mothman

Mini Squishable Dark Forest Mothman

$34.99

$34.99

Mini Squishable Goblincore Mothman

Mini Squishable Goblincore Mothman

$34.99

$34.99

Mini Squishable Goth Christmas Tree

Mini Squishable Goth Christmas Tree

$31.99

$31.99

Mini Squishable Hydra

Mini Squishable Hydra

$37.99

$37.99

Mini Squishable Kittypillar

Mini Squishable Kittypillar

$34.99

$34.99

Mini Squishable Lich

Mini Squishable Lich

$34.99

$34.99

Mini Squishable Mori the Plague Rat

Mini Squishable Mori the Plague Rat

$34.99

$34.99

Mini Squishable Sakura Mothman

Mini Squishable Sakura Mothman

$34.99

$34.99

Mini Squishable Viking

Mini Squishable Viking

$34.99

$34.99

Overthinker Teddy Bear

Overthinker Teddy Bear

$16.99

$16.99

Party Snacker Pink Baby Mothman

Party Snacker Pink Baby Mothman

$22.99

$22.99

Psycho Teddy Bear

Psycho Teddy Bear

$16.99

$16.99

Snugglemi Snackers Dachshund Hot Dog (5")

Snugglemi Snackers Dachshund Hot Dog (5")

$17.99

$17.99

Squishable Snacker Baby Seraph

Squishable Snacker Baby Seraph

$21.99

$21.99

Squishmallows Archie the Axolotl Heating Pad
50% off

Squishmallows Archie the Axolotl Heating Pad

$27.99 $13.99

$27.99 $13.99

Teacup Anxietea Plush

Teacup Anxietea Plush

$16.99

$16.99

The Exorcist Regan 8" Phunny Plush by Kidrobot - Darkside Records
50% off

The Exorcist Regan 8" Phunny Plush by Kidrobot

$16.99 $8.50

$16.99 $8.50

You're My Best-Tea Plush

You're My Best-Tea Plush

$16.99

$16.99